BMM and Modularity

FZD

Space Marshal
Nov 22, 2016
1,388
5,196
2,750
RSI Handle
FZD
Okey, so there's very little modularity currently in game, just a few ships got a room or two you can theoretically swap out but for now they basically resemble variants, so it's easy to forget that pretty much every larger ship is intended to have some modularity. Even the Merchantman.

Here's what the concept sale says:
https://robertsspaceindustries.com/comm-link/transmission/14332-Clipper-Ship-Banu-Merchantman said:
The ship design, perfected by generations of Banu development, is intended to offer a combination of high speed and durability. While the Banu is less configurable than a Caterpillar or a Starfarer, there’s still plenty of room to take the ship in different directions. From black market trade platform to deadly q-ship, it’s a force to be reckoned with!
Strange, I kinda thought BMM was a q-ship by default. I suppose that means you can swap something out for even more hidden guns, or perhaps the idea was that you could swap out the cargo hold for a hangar. This was, of course, written before BMM came with a hangar.
Black market trade platform would probably mean trading some cargo space for shielding the cargo hold.

Now of course the BMM has gone through various redesigns since the initial concept. But there's still certainly room for modularity, so, let's go over which rooms could be altered and how:
Merchantman_Cut-Out_-_Citizen_Con_2021.png


1) Sanctuary. This is honestly probably going to be a pretty useless room for most players. It's a good sized room too, with an elevator access. Pretty deep inside the ship too, so it could be for example a secondary shielded cargo hold for smuggling. Or possibly the battle bridge. Or with the Q-ship being mentioned as an option, one module could be throwing bunch of remote operated turrets around the ship, and then make this the control room for those. This room could honestly be just about anything.
2) Quest rooms. Obviously if you swap these out, you couldn't have quests. But maybe you don't want quests, maybe you want something else. Like passenger cabin to transport some travelers on the side. Well, that's kinda same as quest rooms, but it'd be less of a VIP 1st class and more of a 3rd class.
3) Conference. Bit larger than the quest rooms. There's some options here, like a Carrack-style repair room.
4) Conference + Quest rooms. Take down that wall, and you got a lot more room. You could really have a full-sized 3rd class passenger cabin there. Make it so cramped that the people want to peruse your market rather than remain seated.
5) Markets. That's a good sized space. Could have some exploration themed rooms, like lab space to analyze stuff you find. As the sorta voyaging trader, BMM would probably already have a pretty good range, so exploration wouldn't be a stretch.
Or more quest rooms, to improve the VIP transport capabilities, in which case you could also just replace 3 shops instead of 4, leave one kiosk there.
Or a casino. Casino would be cool.
6) Top turret. If there's exploration options for modules, the top turret could be swapped out to a powerful scanning array. That turret has a huge room anyways, could accommodate a huge dish.
7) Cargo hold. It's literally just a huge empty space with more cubic meters than what medium ships have. There is no limit to what this room could be. It could even be a second hangar. Though of course if it's something other than a cargo hold, then you won't really be doing much trading.
8) Hangar. More large empty space that could easily be something else. Could just fill it with cargo, or divide it into a bunch of smaller rooms, top could be a greatly reduced hangar for a snub ship, below that you could have couple extra rooms for whatever. Actually, could be a whole standalone exploration module, with the aforementioned snub hangar above and then repair room and lab room below that.
Or put like a gigantic fuel tank there and never stop for gas again.

Basically the only bits you can't really touch are Engineering, Bridge, Mess, Hab, Med and docking collar + the corridor there.
Apart from that, there is really no limit to what sorta modularity BMM could have. Of course, CIG could also just scrap the idea of BMM modularity altogether.

What sorta modules would you guys want to see and where in the BMM?
 

Richard Bong

Space Marshal
Jul 29, 2017
2,345
6,525
2,850
RSI Handle
McHale
I'm not seeing what CIG said as modules but as different things the ship can do in its standard configuration.

For example what's the practical difference between a Black Market Bazaar and a normal Bazaar? The goods and the laws of the place you are setting up.

Is it an interesting idea? Sure. Is it likely to happen? No.
 

BUTUZ

Space Marshal
Donor
Apr 8, 2016
3,602
12,199
2,850
RSI Handle
BUTUZ
Cig like to sell you modularity but they so far in 10 years haven't made a single modular ship that we can swap the modules on.

I wouldn't base your ideas and dreams around modularity any time soon as John Crewe seems to hate the idea and blocks it as often as possible.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FZD

Sky Captain

Space Marshal
Donor
Oct 13, 2018
1,837
6,224
2,750
RSI Handle
TheSkyCaptain
The Merchantman is a great-looking ship that I suspect has a lot of potential for future 'variant' roles beyond its current 'bazaar' focus.

Generally I'm just expecting it to fulfill its bazaar role with cargo and market modules mostly, not much more.

For its generally intended role, it might also be cool to have VIP transport and entertainment (disco?) modules? ;-)

But honestly I'd be more interested in seeing its warship potential. A major forward turret instead in place of the main hangar? Torpedo storage instead of a market? A launch bay for a squad of drones or armored vehicles to deploy onto a planet? Oh wait, I own other ships that can do this. Doh!

But a drone ship .... that thought is lingering ....
 
  • Like
  • Glorious
Reactions: FZD and Shiwaz

FZD

Space Marshal
Nov 22, 2016
1,388
5,196
2,750
RSI Handle
FZD
I wouldn't base your ideas and dreams around modularity any time soon as John Crewe seems to hate the idea and blocks it as often as possible.
Oh, certainly. I got BMM because I like the idea of a bazaar ship. But the other day I happened to look at that original concept page and I figured it'd be fun to dream a bit, eh? :like:

The Merchantman is a great-looking ship that I suspect has a lot of potential for future 'variant' roles beyond its current 'bazaar' focus.

Generally I'm just expecting it to fulfill its bazaar role with cargo and market modules mostly, not much more.

For its generally intended role, it might also be cool to have VIP transport and entertainment (disco?) modules? ;-)

But honestly I'd be more interested in seeing its warship potential. A major forward turret instead in place of the main hangar? Torpedo storage instead of a market? A launch bay for a squad of drones or armored vehicles to deploy onto a planet? Oh wait, I own other ships that can do this. Doh!

But a drone ship .... that thought is lingering ....
Yeah, I'd imagine the Banu have some more military focused configurations of the BMM. It'd make sense, security trade is also a trade and I'd imagine some Banu clans would be in that business.

The bazaar would probably make for a pretty cool disco. It's basically shaped like one anyhow.
And drones, yeah. The hangar, for example, wouldn't really require much modifications to start drone operations.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sky Captain
Forgot your password?