Games Workshop is gonna sue somebody

LurchLord

Space Marshal
Apr 30, 2016
187
852
2,300
RSI Handle
LurchLord
Games Workshop sues everybody, everytime, and for any flimsy excuse. At some point you gotta ignore the bully and just do your thing.
Disney did not sue, and the Guardian was more blatand than this.
 

Thalstan

Space Marshal
Jun 5, 2016
2,209
7,864
2,850
RSI Handle
Thalstan
Nah, there's nothing in this. There are so many distinctly divergent characteristics that they would have nothing to stand on.

Of course, facts won't stop greedy assholes from making stupid decisions.
please stop blaming this on greed...
Part of owning IP is that you need to defend it.
Let's imagine a scenario where a company had a set of armor that was visually recognizable. Similar to how Stormtrooper armor or Space Marine armor, is visually recognizable and heavily associated with their company.

Now, let's say that I form a computer game company, or start drawing a comic book that I am selling and profiting off of, etc. It's minimal amount of money, but it's still something.

In that new property, I am using images that are have a similarity to, but not quite the same as the armors that are used by Disney and Games Workshop

If Disney and/or Games Workshop become aware of it and decide that "the juice isn't worth the squeeze" from suing me, they open themselves up to a problem...which is another company can make the argument that these companies have abandoned their trademarks and that they are now free to market direct copies of the (formerly) trademarked items and are allowed to make a profit from them.

Before you start celebrating cheaper prices for these items though, think about the consequences. You are less likely to see new content from these companies. After all, a lot of these models fund development of new model sets, revised rulesets, new IPs, etc. Eventually, companies like GW would go bankrupt, and without something like a marketable line of owned IP, it is highly unlikely that any large company (say Hasbro) would purchase the property. Any company that does purchase it (if any) would be small independent companies that won't have the resources to do much more than provide older additions online in PDF mode. Broken rules won't be fixed, new products, campaigns, or systems won't be developed.

Owning an IP means defending it. Cease and Desist letters and even lawsuits are common, even if there is little merit because they need a definitive ruling or agreement they can point to that says "no, this IP does not infringe" so that the next time someone else does something, they can't point to the other IP and say "they didn't defend it last year, so they abandoned it"
 

Ayeteeone

Space Marshal
Donor
Oct 22, 2018
793
3,057
2,500
RSI Handle
Ayeteeone
lease stop blaming this on greed...
Part of owning IP is that you need to defend it.
I'm not arguing that it's necessary to defend an IP; it very much is these days. The beginning of this thread, however, suggested that one company was going to sue another based on an untenable position. Greed has driven this many times, and I'll put up Strike 3 Holdings as egregious example.


For those who might be interested in copyright law and it's shenanigans, Leonard French is a lawyer with a moderately entertaining channel on YT called Lawful Masses. He likes to look at the actual court documents and relate that to case law, and recently did a show about the kerfuffle between Gamers Nexus and Bloomberg.
 

Lorddarthvik

Space Marshal
Donor
Feb 22, 2016
2,971
10,299
2,860
RSI Handle
Lorddarthvik
Remeber when GW tried to claim Pauldrons in general? As in every single armor ever with a pauldron is theirs now? Yeah, that's not "defending your IP", that's pure evil greed and nothing else.
GW is currently too busy going after their own fans for making and wearing their own cosplay armor... (after they got rid of all fan animations, and tried to get rid of all 3d printers and such lol)
They are trying to become Nintendo, the issue is they don't have the money to buy every judge or the twisted pro-corpo culture of japan standing behind them lol

I get it, you do need to defend your IP. But you also need to turn a blind eye for any chance of having a healthy happy community build around your brand. Disney and the like knows this, they won't go after lil Timmy, 6, for drawing a Micky mouse face on a piece of paper and wearing it on Halloween (at least not anymore). GW does, and it shows in their rapidly dwindling fanbase and sales.

I kinda like that armor, the colors and inlay looks neat, but that skull on the back looks a bit too distorted for my taste.
 
Forgot your password?