Typically, anytime someone throws out that a particular clan/guild/org is bad for the community, it has very little to do with what is actually good or bad for the community.
Jealousy, hurt feelings, anger, revenge, all have been reasons to put down an organization. One way or the other, the reasons tend to be personal and not based on the health of the community as a whole. Good or evil, constructive or destructive, large or small, organizations are really good for any game. Villains create heroes, conflict creates cohesion, and hard won victories create a sense of ownership.
So when someone says that an org like Test is bad for the community, I have to question their logic. So far, since I have become a member, I have found absolutely no reason for the Test hate. The only thing I have found is a solid, helpful, and entertaining community. That leads me to believe that the sentiment lies not with some perceived failure, but rather in Test's success. Because when your guild fails, it is obviously Test's fault. When you can't leave Grim Hex, it's Test's fault. When you stub your toe, it's Test's fault...