Carrack is by far my favorite in the showdown. So knowing that TEST members are probably the source of the MPUV wining... screw you guys.
I had to post this response in a thread on Spectrum:
-----------
"I have no real interest in either the Carrak or the Argo, but It's a popularity contest so I voted for the most popular one.
I've seen a bunch about the Argo, seems to have a strong popular following, but have not seen jack about the Carrak. Where are the "Carrak is love, Carrak is life" memes? Yeah they are old but they are still relevant and you even had them being chanted in official Star Citizen videos and strong-arming hosts to begrudgingly make the ship their favourite one back in the day...
If anyone blames the Argos success on Memes, they gotta accept it's treading a path the Carrak laid...
No criticism intended on either ship or their followers or communities, just answering the OP question. If I could vote for a ship it would be the 350r and that's got no hope of being in the top 16
"
-----------
I didn't realise it at the time, but the above is totally true about the Carrak. The Carrak was life, the Carrak was love, that meme had the crowd and the following even made the Carrak Disco Landos most favouriteist ship (valid until it became flyable) in a vote. It had the hype machine and the cult following and might just still have had that if only there had been the effort... But the cult leaders (owners?) didn't maintain the hype as they believed the ship could now carry itself on its own merits.
But it's a $600 ship. Of all the people who voted Carrak last time, how many actually
owened one? The owners directly experience the merits but the biggest overwhelming demerit of the carrak is it is not a ship the masses can get their hands on and directly experience the merits of themselves.
The cult followers moved on and their new god is actually within attainable and within reach. It's just a bit crummy. Alas, a popularity contest is just that. What is popular isn't always what is best. What is popular doesn't stay that way maintenance to keep it there. Next year, a ship with some capabilities and affordable with the Meme-train behind it will be the recipe for success.
Lets start that work on the Aurora now.