The issue here is that the US isn't an island, no matter how badly some may want the country to be.The US needs trade partners to maintain its position of economic dominance. When your traditional trading partners have their Covid19 cases trending down while yours is still climbing, that's a problem. You can stand on a podium and yell all you want to the heavens that 'America is now Open' but it won't do a lick of good because people still aren't coming. Countries will be reluctant to reestablish the same trade deals, tourists will be fearful of visiting, etc. etc. Unless of course your desire is to make the US an autarkic country that's 'self sufficient'. You know what other countries are 'self sufficient'? North Korea and Venezuela.
Let me tell you right now that kind of economic isolation is suicide. People will dump US treasury bonds in a heart beat. Countries will cease using the US dollar as a foreign reserve currency, folks will stop trading Oil in dollars, and the US Economy WILL collapse. Hyperinflation will set in and we'll all experience something worse than the Great Depression of the 1930s. This is not complex economics here, this is the financial order that we've all been operating under since 1971 (Post Bretton-Woods).
You need to understand that We (The rest of the World) want you guys to do well. I actually WANT Trump to pull through on this because so much is at stake. If he gets reelected because he does a good job in getting us out of this quagmire, more power to him. The industry I'm in for example is watching what's happening in the US nervously. We can't go really go back to work until there's some sort of normalcy and things are under control.
There are some logical fallacies in your arguments.
Covid19 has not stopped most imports/exports in areas were good still exists, some goods are limited/not available but this is not due to trade route disruption so much as manufacturing disruption in the supply chain. Some areas like oil import have caused futures traders to lose cash due to the overstock of oil.
While tourism can/will be impacted by countries with active Covid19 cases for most countries tourism export (those coming to the country) is a very small part of the tourist industry and an even smaller part of a countries GDP. (the industry is 2.8% of the USA GDP, International Tourism accounts for 32% of the total tourism industry) https://travel.trade.gov/outreachpages/download_data_table/Fast_Facts_2017.pdf
So even if no tourist from outside the country came over it would have a small impact on the overall GDP of the USA. Changing the overall countries policy in regard to the current pandemic would not change the country's foreign trade nor lead to a countries attempt at being autarkic. In fact, the two countries you listed as being simi autarkic are not of their own choices but forced upon them by sanctions by the UN. (North Korea still trades heavily with China, Venezuela top three trade partners are USA, China, and India)
Dumping of treasury bonds would hurt the holders of the bonds just as much as it would the US. Of the 22 trillion issued 36% is held by the US Government, 28% is held by foreign countries of that percent China holds 17.3% and Japan holds 16.5%. https://www.visualcapitalist.com/foreign-countries-holding-most-u-s-debt/
Economics has maintained that the overseas demand for the dollar has allowed the US to continue a large trade deficit while not affecting the value of the dollar or cause the trade flow to readjust. But that in the near future these pressures would precipitate a run against the US dollar with serious global financial consequences and a rebalancing of the US trade.
So no the country going back to work would do far more to stabilize the countries economics than the possible loss from tourism. In fact, going back to work now would help establish goods and services that currently are not being met by other countries thus increasing exports and further strengthen the dollar.