Great review. Yeah, I think Jedi Academy was the last of this kind, and I loved that game. I have to say I understand the cheering for single player, because interacting with any other players does tend to break immersion. Almost no one roleplays in group games. So if what you want is something to convince you you're a Jedi for an hour at a time, it would need to be single player. It's that or join a hardcore RP group, and they're not always the most effective players.
I think because there are no skills in SC, when you discuss how to do a thing, you are really talking about doing it, not mimicking it through a game functions, so SC could support a much higher level of immersion in a group dedicated to actual RP. I could be up for that, but needs to start with reasonable handles. No more numbers in your names. No more silly dreadful names like "Reaper" and that ridiculous stuff.
"Hey, Blood Shadow of Merciless Dripping Death, did you put the bon-bons away? They're all over the galley, man."